How to respond to the ‘man made’ climate change debate is difficult for business.  If you run a staff workshop on ‘brand or product development’ you will encounter swathes of ‘foot dragging’ cynicism: and that goes for customers too.  But if you don’t consider the issue, then other stakeholders and ‘interest groups’ may not look on that favourably. 

Now, in spite of the claim that all scientists agree that climate change is mostly man made, we have had yet more contradictory evidence in the last few months: a film in the US ‘An Inconvenient Truth or Convenient Fiction’ and a court case in the UK which has ruled that ‘The Inconvenient Truth’ has overlooked, well, some inconvenient truths of its own. 

Then comes ‘Cool It - A Sceptical Environmentalists Guide to Global Warming’, by Bjorn Lomborg, telling us that no climate model has predicted the Gulf Stream will turn off.  And ‘Scared to Death’ a book by Christopher Brooker and Richard North which tells us that:-

•  The 1998 hockey stick temperature graph is now a totally discredited scientific thesis. The hottest year of the 20^th century was 1934 not 1998.
•  Many scientists now say world temperatures have fluctuated for centuries, and tend to correlate with the radiation from the sun, not CO2 levels.
•  In 1998 the UN’s enquiry into climate change asked 1,500 experts to report. But in the final huge document the prefacing Summary for Policymakers did not include the caveats that the experts reports had put forward.

The book also states, that consumers will not tolerate the drop in living standards that the EU’s 2050 emission targets demand.  In the end it will be the corporate world that needs to react on behalf of customers: and the Carbon Trust is already advertising for innovators to help business develop new ‘low carbon’ technologies. 

Maybe the best way for business is to depoliticise the whole issue and take the middle ground: split climate change away from CO2 emission, both are happening it’s the correlation that the issue .  Saving resources including energy is laudeable; after all it cuts down customer’s energy bills.  Innovating methods of CO2 control will save customers the extra tax they will be charged at least.  Looking after the natural environment enhances well being. 

In addition make sure your staff have access to ‘An Inconvenient Truth’, ‘Convenient Fiction’ and ‘Scared to Death’ as balanced inputs to workshop thinking and corporate debate.